By: Eloise Malle


Trump administration’s refusal to comply with court orders in the Abrego Garcia case reveals a troubling erosion of judicial authority and executive accountability in U.S. immigration policy.

On October 21, 2024 in Concord, NC, U.S. President Trump stated,  “On Day One … We will begin the largest deportation operation in the history of our country.” The Trump administration upheld this initiative, having issued 181 immigration-specific executive actions since January 2025, causing much skepticism over the legality of the orders. Within this rise in deportation, the Abrego-Garcia case represents the Trump administration’s complete disregard for the values that constitute the U.S.’ democracy. Trump’s handling of recent immigration policies resemble the actions of an authoritarian regime.

Since Trump came into office in 2025, over 49,000 migrants have found themselves in ICE detention facilities by April. Most, however, have been unable to receive any form of due process, the concept of having fair treatment in a court of law. The Trump administration has implemented policies used for expedited removal, which promote fast deportations and detract from a fair legal process. Immigrants’ lack of opportunity for legal representation directly contradicts the Fourteenth Amendment, which states: “Nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” When being sworn in, President Trump and his cabinet made a promise to the people of American society, to faithfully execute the duties of the Office of the President, and “preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States.” This attack on immigration is therefore not only a direct attack on the Constitution and the laws that we use to dictate our society, but a refusal from Trump to uphold his presidential obligations. By applying unconstitutional processes, Trump is refusing to uphold and ignoring his duties as President. 

The growth of the role of deportation in the administration’s agenda has become cause for fear even for U.S. citizens. Being a U.S. citizen comes with the rights and protections of the Constitution; however, Trump’s recent policies have begun to distort this reality. As of January 2025, the process of expedited removal, previously applied exclusively to immigrants, can be applied anywhere in the U.S. to individuals who cannot prove they have lived in the country for at least two years. The alarming expansion of expedited removal undermines the rights of non-citizens and even citizens, diminishing the constitutional protections of all people living within the U.S. border. 

The wrongful deportation of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a legal U.S. resident, to El Salvador despite a judicial ban, demonstrates the Trump administration’s disregard for checks and balances. At the age of 16, Abrego Garcia crossed the border illegally from El Salvador to join his brother in Maryland, to escape threats of death or kidnap made by a local gang. Three years later, however, he was arrested in a Home Depot after an officer claimed his clothing was “indicative of the Hispanic gang culture.” He subsequently faced accusations suggesting he might be a member of the MS-13 Salvadoran gang. The case was quickly dropped, and he was granted a “withholding of removal” order, preventing him from any threat of deportation on the basis that he could face harm.

On March 15th, however, Abrego Garcia was sent to a Terrorism Confinement Center in Santa Ana, El Salvador specifically designed for gang members. The legal ruling that had granted Kilmar Abrego Garcia protection and residence on U.S. soil had been obstructed. As the case unfolded, a DHS officer, representing the United States government, called his deportation an“administrative error,” acknowledging the innocence of Abrego Garcia, yet did not rectify the situation. The administration’s decision not to facilitate Abrego Garcia’s return, despite acknowledging his wrongful deportation and receiving clear orders from the judiciary, demonstrates a lack of accountability.  This case, once again, reveals a refusal to faithfully execute presidential responsibilities and suggests that the rights of the people living in the U.S. aren’t at the core of governmental policy. 

The Abrego Garcia case continued to receive traction as it was seen as an abuse of power and was later found to demonstrate an executive disregard for the judiciary. After his deportation on April 10, the District Court for the District of Maryland ordered—and the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed— that he should be returned to his family in the United States. The administration opposed this ruling, bringing it to the Supreme Court of the United States to vacate the lower court’s ruling. The Supreme Court, however, voted in favor of Abrego Garcia, reaffirming the unconstitutional nature of his removal. This unanimous decision was pioneered by Chief Justice John Roberts, who observed that “[t]he United States acknowledges that Abrego Garcia was subject to a withholding order forbidding his removal to El Salvador and that the removal to El Salvador was therefore illegal”.  The rulings in both the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court, both of which concluded in judgments siding against Trump, acknowledge  presidential overreach. Trump’s response, too, displays reactionary disregard for the judicial branch.

ABC News correspondent Terry Moran, in an interview with the president,  referenced the Supreme Court order requiring the administration to “facilitate” Abrego Garcia’s return. He even stated, “You could get him back. There’s a phone on this desk.” To which President Trump replied, “I could. […] And if he were the gentleman that you say he is, I would do that. But he is not.” Trump’s intent to defy a Supreme Court ruling is therefore based on his personal dislike for Abrego Garcia, and demonstrates that his dislike is reason enough to effectively deprive him of his constitutional rights. The actions of the administration exemplify a complete disregard towards the construct of checks and balances. Despite an order from the highest court in the country, the President decided to completely disregard his responsibilities and prioritized his personal preferences over the rule of law. His choice to undermine the authority of the judiciary sets a dangerous precedent towards the destruction of the values that unite us. 

The Abrego Garcia case and its legal repercussions have already set an oppressive judicial standard, permitting an obstruction of checks and balances, and the opportunity for executive overreach in immigration.  In the Noem v. Abrego Garcia case, Justice Sotomayor warned that: “The Government’s argument, moreover, implies that it could deport and incarcerate any person, including U. S. citizens, without legal consequence.” This statement suggests a deeper concern beyond immigration, implying an encroachment of authoritarian tendencies within the U.S. legal system. Authoritarianism, by definition, describes a form of government away from a system of three branches, and towards a centralization of power. When a government begins ignoring the judiciary, as well as the legislature, one can consider a shift away from a democratic model into an authoritarian one. The Trump administration’s initial refusal to acknowledge the Supreme Court ruling and its disregard for the legislation supporting due process for immigrants suggest a descent into this structure of a centralized power. 

One response to “Deported by Disregard: Abrego Garcia and the Collapse of Checks and Balances”

  1. Excellent analysis

    Like

Leave a Reply

Trending