By: Kristen Ma

Trump’s deep-sea mining order bypasses international law and environmental safeguards, escalating geopolitical tensions and threatening ocean ecosystems.

In an interview with The Atlantic, musing on his first 100 days in office, President Donald Trump professed that he “…run[s] the country and the world” (The Atlantic), a redux of his former, inflammatory rhetoric. His hubris, though forward, is not totally unfounded amid his induction of divisive trade wars, most notably with China, coupled with a record-setting spate of 143 executive orders. One such order was Executive Order (EO) 14285. Signed on April 24th, the edict prescribed the acceleration of U.S. deep-sea mining operations in international waters and along the U.S. outer continental shelf in both the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans by expediting the issuance of mining permits (The American Presidency Project). The order marked the first time the U.S. government endorsed the commercial extraction of seabed materials, much less to a scope beyond American jurisdiction. 

Executive Order Unleashing America’s Offshore Critical Minerals and Resources targets the extraction of polymetallic nodules containing manganese, iron, cobalt, copper, and nickel. These materials are crucial in aerospace, defense, energy, and technology industries; currently, China has an unrivaled monopoly over the supply chain through processing and refining. In terms of raw ores, China possesses five of the International Seabed Authority’s (ISA) 30 exploration rights, granting the nation 92,000 square miles of international seabed or 17% of the area sanctioned by the ISA (The Washington Post). In Section 2 Clause F of EO 14285, Trump reasoned that advancing seabed mineral development would “counter China’s growing influence over seabed mineral resources,” which he described as “foreign adversary control” (The American Presidency Project). However, the executive order contravenes provisions of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), which requires permission from the ISA for states to proceed in ocean resource extraction and governing the sanctioned area’s maritime rights. Under UNCLOS, countries have absolute sovereignty over their territorial seas 12 miles from the coast, and economic sovereignty over their exclusive economic zones (EEZs), which extend 200 miles from the coast. Though the U.S. has not been a signatory of UNCLOS since 1982 due to economic and national security concerns, Trump’s blatant overstep attests to his inclination to flout international law in the interest of domestic gain. ISA Head Leticia Carvlho criticized Trump’s apathy, saying, “No state has the right to unilaterally exploit the mineral resources of the area outside the legal framework established by UNCLOS… this prohibition is binding on all States, including those that have not ratified UNCLOS” (Yahoo News). Trump’s unilateral push toward deep-sea mining undermines transnational diplomacy, which could, in turn, escalate geopolitical tensions with China– revealing a prioritization of nationalist resource grabs over global ecological and legal standards. 

Trump’s executive orders have little legal basis, having been founded on the decades-old Deep Seabed Hard Mineral Resource Act of 1980 (DSHMRA) and subverting the ISA’s authority established by the UNCLOS. The DSHMRA stipulates a regime for U.S. citizens to acquire mining licenses, and also facilitates the transition to an international regime provided the recipient guarantees the protection of the marine environment, the conservation of mineral resources, and averts “unreasonable interference with other uses of the high seas” (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration). None of these parameters are expected to be met by the current administration. Washington seeks to spearhead mining for mineral-rich nodules among the furthest depths of the ocean floor, which can alter the geochemical underpinnings of ocean life and destroy entire water columns, obstructing the connectivity between deep oceans and surrounding bodies of water (Center for Biological Diversity). Such concerns pertaining to the ecological ramifications of deep-sea mining were precisely what prompted many U.N. member states to join the U.N.-affiliated ISA in the 1990s. Today, 30 countries–among them China and France–under the aegis of environmentalists, fisheries trade groups, and even select auto and tech companies, have demanded a moratorium on seabed mining (The Guardian). 

The implications of Trump’s initiatives are not restricted to legislative usurpations. Deep-sea mining at the rate and scale in which the Trump Administration proposes poses a risk to the fishing industry, food chains, and the ocean’s absorption of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, at odds with the prevailing consensus that economic imperatives should not take precedence over ecological impact. Drilling and extraction spoil fisheries; a deep-sea mining test revealed a 43% decrease in fish and shrimp density even after one year of recuperation, and a 56% reduction in nearby regions (The Guardian). Mining vehicles ranging from Autonomous Underwater Vehicles (AUVs) and Remotely Operated Vehicles (ROVs) disturb 172.5 tonnes of carbon annually for every square kilometer mined through the creation of sediment plumes (Planet Tracker). Car companies, including BMW, Volkswagen, and Volvo, as well as Apple, Google, and Samsung, have all pledged to prohibit the use of seabed minerals in their products. Trump’s executive also set the stage for the Metals Company, a distinguished seabed mining company, to receive an expedited permit from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Association (NOAA) to mine actively for the first time. The Metals Company’s contract sites are in the Clarion-Clipperton Zone, a region located in the Pacific Ocean off the western coast of Mexico(The New York Times). The company will be the first to apply for an exploitation permit in accordance with the 1980 law (The New York Times). Though the lucrative permits offer unadulterated access to 1.7 million square miles of ocean, it is easily exploited, thus subjecting oceans to prolonged, irreversible environmental fallout.

If Trump’s executive orders were to be executed properly, curtailing U.S. dependence on Chinese supply chains by extension, China is likely to retaliate. As it stands, China has largely reciprocated U.S. tariffs tit-for-tat, raising duties on U.S. goods by 125% in response to Trump’s 145% tariff on Chinese goods (Reuters). China has wrestled for maritime sovereignty before. In 2023, China deployed air defenses, radar systems, and effectively militarized its vessels and maritime facilities to exploit disputed territories in the South China Sea (Bush Center). This struggle for control is projected to be no different. Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun has already condemned Trump’s decrees, contending that seabed resources must be managed exclusively under ISA regulations, and that “the U.S authorization…violates international law and harms the overall interests of the international community” (BBC). As a Group A member of the ISA, China is an advocate for multilateral governance. Group A members possess a major stake in the consumption or export of seabed materials. Its diplomatic engagement makes it likely that the country will portray Trump’s directives as an international concern and recruit other states, notably France and Canada, to mount pressure for the U.S. to reconsider. These countries may emphasize the necessity of environmental evaluations by scientific institutions and Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) prior to commercial-scale mining, and institute maritime joint patrols to monitor the U.S. (South China Morning Post).  The projected statistical increase in mineral demand of 400% by 2040 demonstrates the consequential nature of deep-sea mining and how it can fuel geopolitical competition, particularly with a resource-hungry country such as China. 

In the face of these rising environmental and diplomatic concerns, it is evident that Trump’s actions have eroded the legitimacy of international law and has forced the U.S. onto a pedestal above global interest without limitation. This in turn intensifies existing economic tensions globally, prompting countries like China to place pressure on others to dispute his actions and institute international evaluation processes prior to sanctioning seabed mining permits. In summary, Trump’s executive order promoting deep-sea mining represents a unilateral challenge to international law and environmental responsibility, prioritizing short-term economic gains and geopolitical posturing over the established framework of UNCLOS. 

Leave a Reply

Trending