By: Boson Bai
The October 2025 Ceasefire in Gaza is unlikely to create lasting peace due to misaligned interests, and likely repetition of past problems such as dispute over hostage exchanges.
After half a year of constant disagreements, fighting, and failed negotiations, the two belligerents in the Gaza Strip, Israel and Hamas, see an unlikely ceasefire on the horizon. Though upon first sight the ceasefire seems to be the solution to ongoing bloodshed and poor diplomatic relations, it is doomed to fail for the same reasons as the past January 2025 and November 2024 ceasefires did.
The current situation and history of conflict in Gaza is a tumultuous one of two misaligned actors: Israel and Hamas. According to the BBC, Hamas’ attacks on October 7, 2023, sparked the conflict between Hamas and Israel. The group justified the attack by claiming it was a response to years of oppression, blockades, and the killing of Palestinians.
The key reason why Hamas, a Palestinian Islamist militant and political organization that governs the Gaza Strip, is currently fighting lies mainly in self-preservation and ensuring its sovereignty. Hamas is “unlikely to completely disarm,” according to Azmi Keshawi, a Palestinian from Gaza and a researcher with the International Crisis Group (ICG). Hamas wants guarantees of a ceasefire and the removal of foreign occupiers from its land. It sees armament as critical to sovereignty and maintaining power, says the Atlantic Council.
Israel is currently fighting out of retaliation, hoping to recover all hostages and “destroy” Hamas. This goal stems from Hamas’s long history of launching attacks and its stated opposition to Israel’s existence. By destroying Hamas, Israel also seeks to remove what they see as an ongoing security and ideological threat.
In order to better understand the current ceasefire, let’s look at past ceasefires between Israel and Hamas. Firstly, the 2025 January-to-March ceasefire. The goals of the ceasefire were to create a multi-step plan with the end goal of permanently stopping fighting. “This deal will halt the fighting in Gaza, surge much-needed humanitarian assistance to Palestinian civilians, and reunite the hostages with their families after more than 15 months in captivity,” Biden said to NPR. The ceasefire broke apart due to disputes over hostage release, says NBC. Phase 1 went successfully, with Hamas releasing 25 living hostages in exchange for approximately 1,800 Palestinian prisoners. However, while this initial phase created a brief sense of hope for progress, deeper political and strategic divisions quickly resurfaced. Phase 2 was intended to begin 16 days later, marking a crucial step toward a permanent ceasefire and a potential turning point in the conflict. Yet, these plans unravelled as Netanyahu accepted a proposal to extend the ceasefire by 50 days and reopen discussions about phase 2 — a move Hamas perceived as an attempt to stall or renegotiate terms already agreed upon. Israel’s later demand for additional hostage releases before resuming talks further deepened mistrust, as it signalled shifting priorities and a lack of adherence to the original framework. Ultimately, the breakdown of this process reflected not just logistical disagreements but the profound lack of confidence and competing political goals that continue to prevent any lasting resolution between the two sides. Hamas declined, Israel blocked aid into Gaza, the ceasefire ended, and both sides attacked.
The second notable ceasefire is the November 2024 ceasefire. The goals were to allow for the slowdown of active combat, exchange hostages, and create conditions for a longer-lasting peace, according to the Library of Congress. This ceasefire broke up due to mutual distrust and alleged violations of the ceasefire deal, says Anadolu Agency. Dispute over hostages, similar to the current and 2025 January–March ceasefire, was also a factor in the breakup, says Reuters. Beyond these official reasons, the breakdown was likely motivated by deeper political motives on both sides. For Israel, maintaining military pressure was seen as necessary leverage to ensure future compliance and weaken Hamas’s influence, while for Hamas, extending the ceasefire without tangible political or humanitarian gains risked appearing weak to its supporters. Both sides likely viewed the truce not as a genuine step toward peace, but as a temporary strategic pause — a chance to regroup, rearm, and reposition for future confrontations. In the end, the lack of genuine commitment to long-term compromise made the collapse of the ceasefire almost inevitable.
The current political conditions differ from past ceasefires primarily in the intensity and continuity of the fighting before and after negotiations. Surrounding the November ceasefire were periods of hostility and attacks from Gaza. The IDF expanded ground operations as well, says Security Council Report. There were only indirect negotiations with tentative talks and a brief break in fighting with a prisoner exchange.
Looking at the current ceasefire, Israel and U.S. interests, as reported by the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, lie in the ceasefire and disarmament of Hamas. Hamas does not want to disarm and wants to maintain power. The U.S., as a mediator, proposes a 20-point peace plan, according to Deutsche Welle. Some key aspects of which include: immediate ceasefire, release of remaining Israeli hostages and Palestinian prisoners, Hamas removed from power and disarmed, Palestinian Authority reformed, Israeli withdrawal and no annexation, unimpeded aid flow, economic growth plan, security guarantees for Gaza, and more.
Israeli interests at this time primarily include hostage rescue, disarmament or reduction of Hamas’ military ability, national security, and ensuring control over post-war actions.
Hamas’ interests at this time include a permanent ceasefire, self-preservation (of sovereignty), guarantees of stability and humanitarian aid, and, most importantly, governance of post-war Gaza. International actors right now, including the U.S., are interested in securing the ceasefire and getting humanitarian aid into Gaza.
Due to the misaligned interests of the parties in the ceasefire, it is unlikely to work out. Some statements coming into the ceasefire include Israel’s Netanyahu saying that he is interested in pressuring Hamas to release or recover further hostages (bodies), maintaining that hostage retrieval is the utmost priority. Israel has responded to the delay in returning all the bodies by threatening to restrict the amount of aid flowing into Gaza”, says the BBC.
Hamas is working on the ceasefire agreement to hand over bodies of hostages but not without disagreement with Israel. Hamas reaffirms commitment to the ceasefire, according to PBS. Interests generally center around ending the attacks on Gaza and self-preservation. It seeks the lifting of the blockade and the removal of Israeli forces from Gaza land, says Arab Center DC.
It is clear that the ceasefire is unsustainable, as both parties’ goals are misaligned. Hamas maintains sovereignty versus the destruction and disarmament of Hamas. Ceasefire without disarmament versus total disarmament of Hamas. Request for removal of Israeli forces versus Israeli interest in taking over and removing Hamas in Gaza. Unrestricted aid versus controlled aid. Disagreements over hostage release and body retrieval. Interest in long-term peace versus conditional ceasefire based on Hamas’ cooperation—the end goal being Hamas’ destruction by Israel. There are simply too many disagreements and misaligned goals arising from the ceasefire for it to ever work.
Historical similarities can easily be seen between the current ceasefire and the January–March ceasefire that failed. A clear example is the dispute over hostages. Proponents of the ceasefire claim that the U.S. mediating with a multi-phase plan will enhance the chance of success. Proponents like Trump claim that outside mediators, with Trump’s 20-point plan, will ensure neutrality and better negotiations, as the plan seems fair to both parties, with both removal of IDF forces and return of hostages.
Furthermore, Israel and Hamas as actors have a very all-or-nothing mindset. We see this in past ceasefires where the necessity for compromise led to resumed hostilities. Israel wants the full dismantlement of Hamas, while Hamas wants to remain sovereign and stay armed. Though the 20-point plan acknowledges some parts of both parties’ desires, it fails to completely address both, which is likely to lead to the cessation of negotiations due to misaligned interests.
Observing recent history, we can see that repeated disputes and disagreements generally lead to the breaking of ceasefires. The current ceasefire conditions and terms are extremely similar to the January–March ceasefire. In January, ceasefire conditions included a similar multi-phase plan with the U.S. and others mediating, removal of Israeli forces, retrieval of bodies, and prisoner exchange.
Additionally, proponents’ arguments that international pressure on Israel will have an effect are also unlikely to hold, as Trump sides with Israel. Israel’s leverage with aid is also likely to make Hamas retaliate by not releasing hostages, creating a snowball effect where disputes between the belligerents worsen.
Past ceasefires have failed over similar or developing conditions that we see now. For example, disputes over hostage handovers, alleged violations of ceasefire terms, and disagreements over terms due to misaligned interests. Given that we currently see similar signs of the ceasefire breaking up, it is likely that this ceasefire will not hold.
In conclusion, the current ceasefire is unlikely to last for a prolonged period of time, as its current conditions and terms reflect past ceasefires. The current disputes and disagreements are likely to lead to the collapse of the ceasefire.





Leave a Reply