By Medha Konda

The reasons why Zillow removed their Climate Risk Assessment tool, and what it means for consumers as climate change related weather incidents grow

In an administration marked by regressive climate change rhetoric, namely its scientific disputation of climate change, and refusal to provide data on this crisis, another step backwards happened late November of this year. Zillow, one of the largest real-estate marketplaces in the United States, recently removed its property climate risk metric provided by First Street, after launching the feature in late 2024.  First Street is one of the leaders in climate risk modeling, and is used by prominent institutions like Bank Of America, and is still linked on Zillow’s website, though Zillow no longer posts climate scores on property listings. Many notable groups voiced their dislike of the metric, including the California Regional Multiple Listing Service (CRMLS), the most influential realtor database in America, funded by subscriber fees from realtors and agents. Their primary concern was that the data Zillow provided was unreasonably inaccurate, leading them to pressure Zillow into removing the risk score on a property’s listing. Yet, naturally, a property having a high climate risk score directly correlated with a lack of consumer interest and fewer sales. Furthermore, CRMLS is a database that Zillow pulls a significant amount of data from, so it is in Zillow’s best interest to maintain that relationship. As climate change increasingly affects our daily lives, it becomes increasingly unlikely that purposefully withholding data like this is simply due to accuracy issues, instead painting a picture of how “profit over planet” rhetoric can cause long-term harm.

The methods and users of First Street indicate that inaccuracy was not a major problem with the system. On the contrary, many institutions use their tools, namely NASA, USGS, the United States’ Census, and multiple banking corporations. Without scientific assurance, CRMLS puts itself in a unique position by claiming it’s inaccurate. While these tools have existed for over 5 years, it is difficult for the CRMLS to point to a specific example where the tool incorrectly portrayed an area as being at risk. In a company statement, First Street noted its accuracy in providing wildfire risk data on homes before the infamous Los Angeles fires earlier this year. In fact, the data was more accurate than CalFire’s official maps, demonstrating how their technology outperforms other older sources that consumers reference, like the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s (FEMA) maps. If inaccuracy is not the primary reason why realtors opposed Zillow’s climate risk scoring system, then what could have led Zillow to take down the metric? The answer lies in the ever-growing threat climate change poses to our properties and assets; consumers were pushed away from properties that seemed to be at risk for flooding in a few years. The inevitable drop in sales led realtors to change something, even though the National Realtors Association recommended them to disclose such information. Contrary to these realtors’ efforts, certain studies even show that floodplain homes are currently overvalued by 34 billion dollars in the United States, indicating that current climate risk tools are not doing an adequate job of informing consumers about potential weather events. Rather than allowing the industry to scrounge money by dismissing this pressing issue, the removal of this tool should spark consumers to educate themselves on the climate change-related disasters that can affect their property.

Though the future is unpredictable by nature, there is scientific evidence supporting the idea that climate change-related natural disasters will only increase in frequency. Economic losses as a result of weather incidents have increased tenfold from 5 decades ago, with 2024 in particular having 27 catastrophic events with over 1 billion dollars in damages. In the midst of increased polarization and politicians who diminish the effects of global warming on our planet, consumers are being forced to look out for their own well-being. An asset like a house is owned for a lifetime; therefore, it is in the best interest of consumers and companies to properly assess properties that are at risk of severe weather catastrophes. From an investment perspective, similar to how current realtors who own properties at risk for flooding and wildfires, purchasing such a property now will only lead to devaluation in the future, considering how the climate crisis will increase in magnitude. Even in the absence of environmental concerns, it is clear that sellers are the only beneficiary to this tool going offline. In the face of heavily funded organizations like CRMLS that prioritize profit over the people and planet, it is in the interest of citizens to look out for themselves, rather than join the discourse over why these models are unreliable.

Zillow’s decision to take down climate risk assessment scores from listings represents more than just the inconvenience of having to find data oneself. It undoubtedly shows how it is in a corporation’s best interest to hide the effects of climate change from the people, and is a wake up call for consumers. A prospective buyer stands to suffer by purchasing a property that is at risk of devastating disasters, while a realtor can escape without retribution. In light of how climate change is treated by the current US government and the politicians who represent us, it is left to the people to weigh how climate change will affect ourselves and our assets. Realtors and their organizations like CRMLS do not act with the interests of people in mind, and now consumers are left to search for ways that climate change will affect their properties and lives.

Leave a Reply

Trending