When the future feels uncertain, society chooses to go back in time, hoping that a return to the past will bring back assurance. As defined by the Cambridge Dictionary, conservatism is “a tendency to preserve traditional values and oppose change.” It is a form of resistance to change and a return to the comfort of tradition, normalcy, and historical values.
The roots of this construct originate in the French Revolution of 1789 and the aftermath, driven by radical political change. The fall of the monarchy and the revolution led to France experiencing the Reign of Terror, marked by widespread violence. At least 17,000 people were officially executed, mainly by guillotine, with almost 10,000 deaths occurring in prisons or without trial. The disarray made many desire order and the restoration of stability through a return to a more familiar, authoritarian form of governance. The establishment of the Directory, which handed power to five powerful, wealthy leaders, demonstrates an example of a society drawing back from change and seeking to restore familiarity.
Edmund Burke, a British statesman, referenced this reactionary return of values in his critique “Reflections on the Revolution in France.” In his work, Burke argued that society cannot be remade and that the only way to maintain order is through the preservation of ‘established institutions.’ Additionally, he disregarded change, as he saw it as a source of despotism. The term “conservatism,” pioneered by Burke, therefore began being used in 19th-century France as an effort to prioritize tradition and maintain order.
The development of conservatism continued to progress in the early 20th century, finding itself on the political scene around Europe but also in the United States. The spread of conservatism led to the formation of political parties around the west that uphold the ideals of this political structure. Just like in France, it grew as a reaction to rapid political transformation and against revolutionary and liberal ideals, emphasizing the importance of maintaining and returning to tradition.
After World War I, conservatism began to grow in response to the social and economic changes caused by the war in the United States. In the U.S., the 1920s were marked by the growth of urbanization, leading to the urban share of the population increasing from 51% in 1920 to 56% by 1930. The growth of social movements, like the expansion of women’s suffrage under the 19th Amendment, also began to demonstrate itself. An economic shift away from a more laissez-faire system, a trend that had been demonstrating itself for two decades, continued to be signed into law, significantly regulating monopolies. Lastly, continued globalization, a clear aftermath of World War I, meant that many Americans wanted to return to a reality where their government prioritized the interests of the people over foreign conflicts and relations. This reality meant that in 1920, Warren G. Harding was elected under the slogan “Return to Normalcy.” However, in 1923, Harding experienced a sudden death, caused by a heart attack, leading his Vice President Calvin Coolidge to take office. Coolidge pioneered traditionalism and promised to return to what once was the norm and was even reelected in 1924. On September 29th, 1923, the Literary Digest provided this description of him: “President Coolidge is pledged to the preservation of ‘stability.’” During his presidency, he passed the Revenue Act of 1924 and then 1926, reducing federal spending and the national debt. Coolidge’s administration also supported traditional values, stating, “Tradition and custom, it will be seen, are oftentimes determining factors in the Presidential office, as they are in all other walks of life. This is not because they are arbitrary or artificial, but because long experience has demonstrated that they are the best methods of dealing with human affairs.” The quote highlights the influence of customs and traditions held in his form of governance. Additionally, he demonstrated conservative social values and nativist priorities when he had the John Reed Act passed, restricting quotas on immigration from Southern and Eastern Europe and completely barring immigrants from Japan. This was an attempt to preserve U.S. culture and maintain similar demographics, which had shifted significantly under Presidents Roosevelt and Wilson. The president’s efforts demonstrate an attempt to move back away from the social and economic changes and a preservation of tradition and values, a concept key to conservatism.
Since its birth in the French Revolution, conservatism has functioned as a return to tradition in response to societal disruption and social change. In the United States, conservatism demonstrated itself as a shift to avoid a future that felt uncertain and back towards one that is clearly defined and highlights traditional societal values. It is a reaction to political change, and the reason politics is often seen as practicing bureaucratic policies, leading to a one-step-forward, one-step-back approach to governance.





Leave a Reply