The German philosopher Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel didn’t consider change to advance in a linear manner but through a struggle where every established order is provoked by an opposing construct resulting in the compromise of progress. In his major work, Elements of the Philosophy of Right, Hegel describes progress as occurring in three stages: concrete, abstract, and absolute. The progression from one  stage to the next makes contradictions or inconsistencies arise, and through the attainment of a conclusion, the abstract and opaque beginning ends with a more concrete and advanced final product. 

Johann Gottlieb Fichte used a similar triadic idea as Hegel, built on the terms thesis, antithesis and synthesis. Fichte, unlike Hegel, applied his theory to describe all social and political processes. Every established order, or thesis, was therefore destined to be faced with an opposite force, the antithesis. From this struggle would a synthesis be produced carrying aspects of the past, but also the compromised new. However, Fichte’s argument doesn’t consider the aftermath that all change is eventually faced with. After significant effort is invested to deliver reforms, the human being’s distaste for change and the redistribution of power cause the inevitable existence of backlash. 

The United States exemplifies Hegel’s and Fichte’s constructs in the structure of its government.  When passing legislation, a majority is needed in both the House of Representatives and the Senate. This process takes much time, discussion, and the representation of all parties to ensure stability and make reforms sustainable, allowing for a synthesis to arise out of discussion. The existence of these constraints is essential, as the purpose of a democracy is to drive political change in a way that is representative of the people, fulfilling the goals of a hegemonic system. If a bill were to be passed, society would be challenged by the bill. For this bill to pass, a synthesis must be found, this thesis and anti-thesis that reflects the will of the majority. In theory, this would produce a Hegelian absolute, a final conclusion that is durable and concrete. Democratic governance, due to its representative nature, can often lead to reactionary forces that can limit or even reverse any accomplished change. Modern democracies are intentionally built upon a form of gradualism, where significant change occurs through a slow, representative process. 

However, democratic decision making, although passing with a synthesis, will always lead to some form of backlash or new resistance as groups often find themselves threatened by change, resisting and defending the status quo. Even after significant effort is invested to deliver reforms, the human being’s distaste for change and the redistribution of power cause the inevitable existence of backlash. 

The Civil Rights Movement demonstrates a period of intense political upheaval culminating in the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965. By the time these laws were enacted, a decade into the movement, there was enough legitimacy and public agreement to allow them to pass in the American legal framework. The Civil Rights Act of 1964, first introduced on June 20, 1963, required extended debate, procedural obstacles, and the mobilization of a national movement that had grown in visibility and legitimacy to end up getting signed into law on July 2, 1964. The victories of the movement were not the result of one event but the culmination of efforts, leading to the evolution of the thesis through the antithesis and resulting in the synthesis. Yet they also brought visible disruption to the status quo, prompting resistance among those who felt that the change was too significant.

The enactment of both acts led to conservative politicians who opposed the change appealing to voters uneasy with the scope of social advancement. Although this didn’t completely remove the progress, it had significant effects on the political landscape for years to come and prevented any further democratic policies. The existence of resistance demonstrates that all decision making doesn’t end upon a conclusion, and this conclusion is only the start of the much political upheaval that results from any decision. 

Alexis de Tocqueville once stated that “A democratic people will always have a tendency to moderate their principles; it is the necessity of their government.” His statement argues that the evolution of change does not occur without the existence of restrictions. Democratic forms of government, by being built on Fichtiean and Hegelian principles, call for the formation of a consensus representative of all people. This means that all evolution is met with a form of backlash, resulting in governance, as Hegel stated, occurring in an almost cyclical manner. Effective political change must be built on the will of the people, and therefore, change ends up finding itself restricted and prevented.

Leave a Reply

Trending