Conservatism in the U.S. has shifted from a philosophy grounded in tradition to a populist movement that demonstrates itself as the voice of ordinary people standing against the elite. This movement has led to evidence of democratic backsliding, a gradual weakening of institutions and political structures, undermining both the constitution and American democracy, and thrusting US society into uncharted territory. 

Since the first American conservative party, the Federalist Party, conservatism has seen small shifts in the policies that leaders advocate for, but it has consistently defined itself through the preservation of tradition. They have always prided themselves on being the most accurate interpreters of the Constitution, effectively maintaining tradition and the foundational values that dictate American society. The Cincinnati revolt of 1977 led to the rise of the New Right movement and the beginning of the NRA’s becoming politically active. This conservative movement firmly opposed most gun control policies, such as the 1994 Federal Assault Weapons Ban, under the argument that they demonstrated governmental overreach and a lack of respect for the Constitution’s Second Amendment, affirming the right to bear arms. In the 2008 District of Columbia v. Heller case, there was a solidification of this conservative victory when the Supreme Court affirmed the individual’s right to own firearms unconnected to militia service. However, the parties’ grounding in maintaining and restoring America as it was intended by the founding fathers has shifted. Although there is still evidence of fidelity towards the constitution, the movement has increasingly prioritized power over tradition.

The modern conservative movement in the United States, MAGA, although incredibly abiding by the Constitution on the topic of gun control, chooses to ignore it on the topic of religion. The First Amendment clearly establishes a separation between church and state, highlighting that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion […] or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” These two clauses explicitly demonstrate that the constitution guarantees the protection of a freedom to practice one’s faith, but also the prevention of a government establishing or favoring a particular official religion. However, many republican leaders have advocated for policies demonstrating clear religious ties, like pushing for a Christian prayer in school or efforts to enforce one religion in the US, Christianity. The limitation of abortion is another clear example, due to the belief that an abortion goes against the Bible. The overturning of Roe v. Wade by conservatives and the pro-life movement violates the Establishment Clause, demonstrating leanings favoring one religious belief over the rights of American citizens. The MAGA movement’s push to intertwine church and state, therefore, opposes the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause and the Founders’ explicit goal of preventing government from endorsing or enforcing a religion. These evolutions cause many to question conservatives and have led many to believe that, although the entire grounding of the movement is on the defense of the Constitution and the maintenance of tradition, the party adheres to the document when it aligns with their agenda but dismisses it when it does not. In addition to opposing the principles of what being a conservative is, the current American right has demonstrated a version of populist conservatism that has led to the erosion of many democratic principles. 

Conservatism has held a populist aspect since the Regan era, exemplified through President Ronald Reagan’s claim that “the nine most terrifying words in the English language are: I’m from the government, and I’m here to help.” The growth of the “ people” against the “elites” movement under President Trump is a clear demonstration of Reagan’s populist form of conservatism, fostering polarization and the erosion of trust in institutions. On January 6th. After the 2020 presidential election, prominent conservative leaders and media figures promoted false claims that the election was “stolen,” fueling the belief in a corrupt elite. Thousands of supporters stormed the U.S. Capitol under the belief that they were defending the real America. For a party that prides itself in the return to tradition and respect for values and governance, this insurrection opposes all of its key values. The event demonstrates a direct attempt at unverifying a democratic election, a clear opposition to the constitutional process. This disrespect for the constitution, and the democratic values that unite the American people, furthers the idea that this new conservatism isn’t based on principle but power.  

The addition of President Trump demonstrated attempts to disrupt the system through his influence in the judicial system and in regulatory bodies. The administration introduced several lifetime appointments to federal courts and three Supreme Court justices. These appointments were made in an attempt to reshape the courts around his political beliefs, undermining impartiality in the judicial branch. His efforts to target federal agencies, including the Federal Reserve by removing its independence and the Department of Justice by replacing hiring loyalists and criticizing investigations into his associates, like Walt Nauta and Carlos De Oliveira. These efforts demonstrate a clear attempt to disrupt the checks and balances, effectively causing the executive branch to hold more power than hoped for by the Founding Fathers. 

Political scientists define democratic backsliding as the erosion of democratic norms and institutions, and over the past two decades, democratic backsliding has become a defining trend in global politics. It has played a key role in anti-democratic efforts and the mechanisms they entail.  In the United States, the conservatives have demonstrated evidence of backsliding in their attempt to invalidate an election, their selective approach to constitutional interpretation, and the adjustment of their agenda based on power and not promise.

In 1936, Harold D. Lasswell said, “Politics is who gets what, when, and how.” Although outdated, Laswell’s words in defining politics as the struggle over the distribution of power and resources in society remain accurate. His definition highlights the modern conservative movement, which has abandoned much of its traditional philosophy in an effort to pursue and maintain power. This shift has meant that the form of populist conservatism that now rules in the US, instead of being based on the restoration of tradition or the constitution, is based on the effective maintenance of power. When a movement that was based on a return to the status quo suddenly drives itself in a direction that none can predict through populist appeals and constitutional contradictions, it leads one to question the future of American democracy and the trustworthiness of its political institutions. How can one have any trust in political parties, their beliefs, and what they stand for when one of the main parties in the largest democracy in the world directly opposes its mission?

Leave a Reply

Trending