History has shown, through various crises in which leaders from Eisenhower to de Gaulle have navigated internal conflict, that the Transatlantic Alliance has remarkable resilience and continues to benefit its member states today. In particular, the alliance has brought the U.S. a collective deterrent against military threats, a productive economic partnership with Europe, and ideological hegemony under democratic values, allowing it to become a global superpower.

However, since his inauguration in January 2025, U.S. President Trump’s foreign policy stance on Europe has somewhat resembled a pendulum, swaying between aggressive and compromising approaches to the Transatlantic Alliance. He started with a series of big, scary announcements — that the U.S. “needs to have Greenland,” that Article V “has many meanings” undermining U.S. responsibility to defend NATO, and that the EU would suffer tariffs as high as 50%. Then, this summer, the president swung back on many of these same issues. He adopted a tougher stance against Russia, shipping armaments to Ukraine and setting a 50-day ceasefire deadline. In recent trade talks with the EU, Trump has also eased tariff threats, decreasing the baseline rate to 15%. To preserve the Transatlantic Alliance, the Trump administration must not swing again, but continue to develop constructive military and economic solutions that emphasize common goals rather than isolate the U.S. from European allies.

With no end in sight for the Ukraine War, the U.S.’s priority is to reaffirm its sincere commitment to defend European allies. When U.S Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth declared in February that the U.S. was no longer “primarily focused” on Europe in order to divert military attention to China, many worried that the U.S would spend less on military aid and send troops stationed in Europe to Asia instead. The U.S. should refrain from such a withdrawal before NATO partners develop their own capacity to deter Russian aggression. Upgrading Europe’s deterrent takes time. As a result, evacuating U.S. soldiers immediately will not only be logistically demanding, but also dangerous – Europe has limited capacity to retaliate against increased Russian hostility without U.S. weapons and personnel. The resulting weakness will become an incentive for Putin to further threaten Europe’s security – whether that means escalating the offensive in Ukraine or threatening nearby countries such as Moldova. The U.S should instead supervise that NATO allies are spending their promised 5% GDP on the military to bolster their defences. In the meantime, Trump must continue his hard line against Russia and rule out a peace settlement that gives Moscow heavy territorial gains. The only message he should send to Putin is that there is no discount for Europe’s security, and the U.S. will defend its allies until it no longer needs to. This way, the U.S. can retain its military leadership and leverage the collective power of the Transatlantic Alliance to stand up against threatening actors such as Russia and China.

Meanwhile, Trump must rescind ambitions of seizing territory of transatlantic allies, especially Greenland and Canada. Greenland’s rare earth deposits appeal to Trump, who refuses to rule out acquiring them by force. The materials are critical in the AI race against China, which is currently exploiting U.S. tech companies’ reliance on these critical minerals. However, the idea of invading Greenland to obtain its resources is unwarranted and provocative. Denmark has administered Greenland, now an autonomous territory, for 800 years, making any attempt to seize it an act of aggression. Furthermore, the U.S.-Greenland memorandum of understanding (MOU) in 2019 already promotes cooperation in the mining industry, including jointly funded explorations for new rare earth deposits in Gardar Province. The desire to make Canada the 51st state is another example of Trump’s nationalist rhetoric which envisions a world power controlling extensive territories. But annexing Canada against its citizens’ will is anantiquated concept harkening back to 19th-century imperialism. Trump must understand that in the world of 2025, respect for sovereignty, of a country as small as Denmark or as large as Canada, is a basic principle in international relations and the bedrock of multilateral trust. Additionally, the U.S.’s expansionist views could encourage other countries to undermine sovereignty of the Arctic region and elsewhere, such as Russia’s presence in Svalbard and China’s appetite for infrastructure in Greenland itself. Failing to address this slippery slope will degrade U.S. relations with European allies. Withdrawing his earlier statements of annexation is thus a prerequisite for a Transatlantic Alliance that will continue to respect and benefit the United States.

From an economic viewpoint, U.S.-EU negotiations have allayed fears of an all-out trade war. Nevertheless, the U.S. should remain cautious to avoid tensions that strain transatlantic cooperation. Tariffs on EU exports aim to mitigate the U.S.’s $230 billion trade deficit in goods against Europe. The discrepancy, though, is less serious than it seems since the U.S.’s trade surplus in services narrows the net deficit to $161 billion. However, Trump’s tariff solution would cause more harm than good not only by raising prices for the average U.S. consumer, but also damaging transatlantic investment, which scholars Daniel Hamilton and Joseph Quinlan describe as “the backbone of transatlantic commercial activity.” Europe alone accounted for 56% of U.S. global Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) outflows, far ahead of the Asia-Pacific (17%) as the second largest destination. Thousands of U.S. businesses produce goods and services in Europe for local markets. Exorbitant tariffs, coupled with retaliatory measures, hurt these transatlantic operations and business confidence, wreaking havoc to supply chains not ready to handle heavy taxes on steel and aluminum. A trade war, in other words, isolates the U.S. economy from its main overseas market, striking everyday citizens with more expensive products from SUVs to champagne and job loss. In fact, FDI to Europe already fell by $240 billion between 2017-18 during Trump’s first term, a decrease larger than the trade deficit itself. The administration must take these disruptions into mind and resist a band-aid solution to trade imbalances that could cause long-term economic loss.

Just as misleading is the claim that the U.S. must move away from Europe to focus on containing China’s economic growth. Since launching the Belt and Road Initiative and drastically stepping up its export volume, Beijing has started to play an outsized role in the European economy. This trend will accelerate if the U.S. abandons its economic ties to Europe, allowing the EU to slowly slip into China’s sphere of influence. In other words, the Trump Administration risks creating a global trade system without itself, in which rival nations such as China court each other and avoid the tariff-ridden U.S. market. Having established Europe’s strategic importance to the U.S. economy, the only viable option is to reconsider its reckless mercantilism in favor of a lasting transatlantic partnership.

Trump’s calculating style of foreign policy might be convincing as an approach putting U.S. citizens first. However, he must not swing away from the EU, a $20 trillion economy, a military power with 1.5 million active personnel, and a partner for the U.S. in areas as diverse as aerospace and the arts. The administration should consider the myriad of ways the Transatlantic Alliance enriches the U.S. Though Trump’s recent changes of heart are promising, he must follow through with more action to re-establish the United States’ credibility as an ally. If the president wants his country to be the “great” one on the world stage, he at least needs to show that it is a nation worth working with.

Leave a Reply

Trending