By Landon Maloney

In 2016, the United Kingdom voted to leave the European Union, marking a turning point in European politics. The Brexit campaign promised to restore national sovereignty and return political power to British citizens. Brexit supporters saw leaving the EU as a chance to reclaim control over the country’s future. Critics, however, warned that nationalist appeals could deepen political divisions and undermine international cooperation. Nearly a decade later, similar movements have gained influence across Europe and the United States. France’s National Rally, Germany’s Alternative for Germany (AfD), Italy’s Brothers of Italy, and the MAGA movement in the United States have attracted voters through messages emphasizing national identity, immigration restrictions, and distrust of established political institutions. National pride, immigration enforcement, and criticism of international institutions are not necessarily incompatible with democracy. Citizens must be free to debate these issues. That said, a concern emerges when leaders portray certain groups as less deserving of rights or attempt to weaken the institutions that hold governments accountable.

Although far-right movements often promise to unite citizens through national identity, that unity can become exclusionary when political leaders blame minorities, immigrants, and opponents for national problems. These manufactured divisions contribute to unequal rights, weakened institutional checks, and restrictions on civil liberties, weakening a country’s democratic foundation.

Italy demonstrates how nationalist politics can move from the political margins into government. Giorgia Meloni’s Brothers of Italy became the leading party in Italy’s right-wing coalition after the 2022 general election, and Meloni became prime minister. The party’s success nationally reflects the appeal of national sovereignty, traditional social values, and stricter immigration controls. Supporters argue that these efforts promote concerns neglected by long-established parties. The electoral success of a party, however, does not eliminate the need to scrutinize a government’s policies and their consequences for basic human rights. When governments weaken protections for minority groups or restrict civil liberties, they undermine the principle that all citizens deserve equal treatment under the law. This threatens democracy by allowing leaders to concentrate power and reducing the ability of citizens and institutions to hold them accountable. Freedom House’s Freedom in the World 2026 report continued to classify Italy as “Free”, while identifying concerns involving the rights of migrants in the country and LGBTQ people. These issues illustrate the distinction between legitimate policy disagreements and questions of democratic accountability in a country. Governments can enforce immigration laws, but those laws must remain subject to rightful processes and human rights protections. Similarly, controversial social policies deserve scrutiny when they affect equal access to services or the rights of marginalized groups.

The issue is not whether Italy should maintain older national traditions or control its borders. It is whether those political goals can be pursued while preserving equal protection of all people under the law. Democracy requires governments to remain accountable for how their decisions affect everyone, including people who lack political influence.

Germany’s AfD offers another example of nationalist expansion. Founded in 2013, the party initially focused on opposition to the euro and European economic policies. Immigration restrictions, nationalism, and opposition to multiculturalism later became increasingly prominent in its platform. In Germany’s 2024 European Parliament election, the AfD received 15.9 percent of the vote and won 15 seats. Its electoral performance established it as a significant political force. German authorities have scrutinized the party over concerns about right-wing extremism. These concerns carry particular weight in a country whose democratic institutions were rebuilt following Nazi Fascism. Criticism of immigration policy, the EU, or German foreign policy is a legitimate part of democratic debate. The more serious questions concern whether political movements respect constitutional protections, equal citizenship, and the legitimacy of democratic opposition. The AfD’s positions on Russia and military assistance to Ukraine also demonstrate how nationalist movements can influence foreign policy debates. Such positions should be evaluated on their merits rather than treated as inherently anti-democratic. By pushing extreme rhetoric, the party risks dividing society and harming equal rights for all citizens. Their ties to extremist groups have drawn serious warnings from government watchdog agencies. Criticizing core democratic institutions weakens public trust in the rules that keep the country stable. This creates a dangerous conflict with Germany’s strict post-war laws designed to prevent anti-democratic movements from taking power. The broader question is whether political competition continues to operate within constitutional boundaries.

Germany’s experience highlights a difficult balance. Political parties must address legitimate public concerns without normalizing extremism or weakening democratic protections. Dismissing dissatisfied voters can deepen distrust, but ignoring threats to constitutional rights can carry consequences of their own.

The V-Dem Institute’s Democracy Report 2026 highlights concerns about democratic backsliding in established democracies, including the United States and Italy. Polarization can weaken institutional independence, political competition, and civil liberties, especially when leaders portray opponents as enemies or reject institutions that challenge them. Democracy depends on independent courts, a free press, and citizens’ ability to criticize their governments without retaliation.

Understanding why nationalist movements gain support is equally important. Economic insecurity, immigration concerns, and distrust of established parties can make their promises of national identity and political control appealing. Not every supporter opposes democracy, and electoral success alone does not prove democratic breakdown. Governments should address voters’ concerns while protecting equal rights and constitutional safeguards. The dividing line is not between people who feel patriotic and those who do not, but between politics that preserves accountability and politics that undermines it. These movements’ long-term effects will depend on how they govern and whether democratic institutions remain effective.

Political change is not anti-democratic. Voters must be free to choose different policies. Danger, however, emerges when governments weaken courts, restrict human rights, undermine media freedom, or limit political competition. From Brexit to Brothers of Italy to the AfD, nationalist populism has gained influence by promising sovereignty and responding to public frustration. National pride does not automatically threaten democracy, but exclusion and weakened accountability can break it down. A nation’s identity should unite citizens without denying equal rights or placing any government, party, or majority above the law.

Leave a Reply

Trending