By Mac Twombley

Britannica defines gerrymandering as the practice of drawing the boundaries of electoral districts in a way that gives one political party an advantage over its rivals, often diluting the voting power of members of racial or ethnic minority groups. In the United States, both sides of the aisle use it to gain political influence over a certain region or alter election results on the federal level. They do this by utilizing state legislature powers to redraw political boundary maps. Techniques known as cracking and packing are used to get the desired election results.

Cracking is when districts are drawn specifically to break up or “crack” a specific voting group. If there was a district where voters usually swung to the left, the right-leaning party could break that district into several and give each piece to a larger district whose right-leaning votes would supersede the left-leaning votes, effectively eliminating a left-leaning seat.

Packing occurs when districts are intentionally designed to include as many individuals of a specific affiliation as possible. If a left-leaning party wanted to minimize the votes of the right-leaning party, they might draw the district in a way that captures the majority of right-leaning voters. This way, not only might they avoid influencing results in other districts, but they are also prevented from sending more than one representative to Congress.

Regarding the upcoming midterm elections, parties have made several attempts at gerrymandering. In Texas, lawmakers approved a map that would give Republicans 5 extra seats in the House. California responded with a map that would give the Democrats 5 extra seats, effectively nullifying Texas’ attempts to aid the Republicans. In Virginia, voters approved a Gerrymandered map that would aid the Democrats, but it was struck down by the Virginia Supreme Court. 

The structure of the American two-party system, combined with the political incentives, explains why gerrymandering remains so prevalent in the United States today. Gerrymandering has come to shape the House of Representatives in ways that significantly affects the integrity of our democracy. We see these show up in three main pillars.

The first pillar is defined as skewed election outcomes. Because of how maps have been drawn in several states, election outcomes aren’t always proportional to the votes in that state. A great example of this is the 2018 House election in North Carolina. Democrats and Republicans received about an equal share of the vote, with the Republicans being slightly ahead by only a very slim margin. While the vote was essentially a 50/50 split, because of how the boundaries were drawn, ten went to Republicans, and only three went to Democrats. This is obviously not proportional to what people voted for, and it is a product of gerrymandering.

The second is the competitiveness of House seats. Virtually all House races today are decided long before voters go to the polls. When politicians draw gerrymandered maps, they ensure that they guarantee the result they are seeking, leaving few districts as competitive races. The Cook Political Report rates a mere 17 House races as “toss-ups” out of all 435 seats for the upcoming midterm elections.

The third pillar is lower voter turnout caused by gerrymandering. Because politicians pack or split voters into districts that are no longer competitive or not representative of that voters views. This leads to people not showing up to vote because they feel as if their vote has been suppressed by gerrymandering efforts.

Our political system could be made more equitable. The electoral system in most other developed nations has already been altered to either include districts while ensuring the final makeup of the governing body is proportional or doing away with districts and electing the governing body purely by the percentage of votes they received. But this will never happen. The only people who can change the federal law that prevents changes like this from happening are those in Congress. However, those in Congress are the ones who have been elected under our disproportionate, gerrymandered system. An unhealthy cycle has formed where we will never have politicians who desire to make our voting fairer because if they made it fairer, it would jeopardize their power and their influence. This is why gerrymandering remains a persistent problem in America and why there is no straightforward solution to address it.

Leave a Reply

Trending